Downtown Buffalo, New York skyline featuring the Electric Tower, Gold Dome, and Lake Erie waterfront, home to The Maitland Group LLC GEICO Exclusive Agency
Proudly Serving Buffalo & Western New York

Your Home. Your Vehicles. Your Valuables.

Insurance Options for What Matters Most.

Craig Maitland and his Buffalo team help families and individuals across Western New York find coverage for their homes, vehicles, boats, and valuables. Stop by the office or call and talk with someone who knows the region.

Serving Buffalo, Tonawanda, Amherst, and surrounding communities. Licensed in NY, NC & FL.

GEICO Local Office logoGEICO Exclusive Agency

3618 Delaware Ave, Suite 400

(716) 517-3300

Craig Maitland, Agency Owner of The Maitland Group LLC, a GEICO Exclusive Agency serving Buffalo and Western New York
GEICO Exclusive Agency

Craig Maitland

Agency Owner · Serving Buffalo & Western New York

About Craig Maitland

Local Connections. Personal Service.

Insurance should start with a conversation. I'm Craig Maitland, and I own The Maitland Group LLC, a GEICO Exclusive Agency at 3618 Delaware Ave in Buffalo. My team and I help individuals and families across Western New York explore coverage for their homes, vehicles, boats, and valuables.

I've spent more than 25 years in the insurance business, including 21 years in leadership and management. I started my career in New York City and had the opportunity to build a team that served clients across the tri-state area. Along the way, I learned that good coverage comes from listening first, explaining options clearly, and following up after the paperwork is signed.

I opened my own office in Buffalo because I wanted to bring that experience home to Western New York. Here, you can walk in, call, or send an email and talk with someone who knows the region's roads, weather, and neighborhoods, and who will still follow up after your policy starts.

I'm proud to be part of this community. My office supports the Kenmore-Tonawanda Chamber of Commerce and the Amherst Chamber of Commerce. We're also proud to sponsor local athletic programs and organizations, including Healthy Buffalo, the Ronald Langhorne Golf Foundation, UB Athletics, and multiple Little League and hockey teams.

Experience & Credentials

Licensed in New York, North Carolina, and Florida

  • 25 years of professional insurance experience with GEICO
  • Over 20 years in insurance leadership and management
  • Licensed in New York, North Carolina, and Florida

Have a question about your coverage? Call (716) 517-3300 or email geabuffalo@geico.com. We'd be happy to talk it through.

Connect With Craig's Office

Insurance Options

Coverage Options for Every Part of Your Life

From the driveway to the waterfront, explore insurance options for the things that matter most.

Auto Insurance

From lake-effect snow and potholes to commuting on Route 33, driving in Western New York brings its own challenges. Explore auto insurance options suited to your driving needs and local conditions.

Homeowners Insurance

From historic Buffalo homes to newer builds in Amherst and Clarence, Western New York homeowners face everything from heavy snow to strong windstorms. Explore coverage options to help protect your home.

Jewelry & Valuables

Whether it's an engagement ring, family heirloom, or valuable collection, the things that matter most deserve careful consideration. Ask about available insurance options for your treasured possessions.

Boat & Watercraft Insurance

From boating on Lake Erie to weekends on the Niagara River, Western New York offers plenty of opportunities to get out on the water. Explore available insurance options for your boat or watercraft.

Motorcycle & Recreational Vehicles

Western New York's scenic roads and seasonal adventures make motorcycles and recreational vehicles a popular way to explore. Ask about available insurance options for your next adventure.

Additional Insurance Needs

From everyday essentials to seasonal hobbies, Western New York residents have a variety of insurance needs. Contact our office to discuss other available products and coverage options.

What You'd Pay

Insurance Costs by State

Insurance costs vary depending on where you live, the coverage you select, and your individual circumstances. Here's how published state averages compare across New York, North Carolina, and Florida — the states where Craig Maitland is licensed to offer insurance.

Average annual insurance premiums by state, client-provided NAIC state averages
StateAverage Annual Homeowners PremiumAverage Annual Auto Insurance Expenditure
Florida$2,437$1,865
New York$1,628$1,753
North Carolina$1,311$1,127

Insurance premiums can differ significantly by state. Factors such as location, weather exposure, property characteristics, driving history, selected coverage, and other underwriting considerations can influence what an individual pays.

Source: National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC), client-provided state averages. Reporting year and publication references pending verification.

Disclaimer: Figures shown are industry averages provided for educational purposes only. They are not GEICO premiums, offers, or quotes. Actual insurance costs vary based on eligibility, coverage selections, location, underwriting, and other factors.

Call Our Office

State Requirements

Understanding State Minimum Auto Insurance Requirements

Auto insurance requirements vary by state. Understanding the minimum coverage required where you live is an important starting point when reviewing your insurance options.

New York

Current requirements

Bodily injury liability
$25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident
Property damage liability
$10,000 per accident
Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
$50,000 (New York is a no-fault state)
Uninsured / Underinsured motorist
$25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident
Source: New York State Department of Financial Services

North Carolina

Effective July 1, 2025 (for policies issued or renewed on or after that date)

Bodily injury liability
$50,000 per person / $100,000 per accident
Property damage liability
$50,000 per accident
Uninsured motorist coverage
Required
Underinsured motorist coverage
Required (included in new or renewed policies beginning July 1, 2025)
Source: North Carolina Department of Insurance

Florida

Standard private passenger vehicle requirements

Personal Injury Protection (PIP)
$10,000 minimum
Property Damage Liability (PDL)
$10,000 minimum
Bodily Injury Liability (BIL)
Not required for standard private passenger vehicles (required for taxis and certain other circumstances)
Source: Florida Department of Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles

Disclaimer: State minimum insurance requirements may change and may not provide enough protection for every driver. Coverage availability and requirements depend on individual circumstances. Contact our office to discuss your options.

Call Our Office
Buffalo, New York waterfront on Lake Erie at blue hour with recreational boats moored at a marina, representing the Western New York communities The Maitland Group LLC serves
Western New York Community: Lake Erie, Buffalo River, and surrounding neighborhoods

Western New York Connection

Proudly Serving Buffalo and Western New York

From the neighborhoods of Buffalo and Tonawanda to the communities of Amherst, Williamsville, and beyond, The Maitland Group LLC is proud to serve Western New York.

Life in this region brings a variety of insurance considerations, from lake-effect winters and homeownership to summer boating on Lake Erie. Craig Maitland's local office provides a convenient place to discuss your insurance needs and explore available options.

BuffaloTonawandaKenmoreAmherstWilliamsvilleCheektowaga

Why Choose Us

A Local Office. A Personal Connection.

Working with a local agency means someone who understands Western New York homes, lifestyles, and seasons is helping you navigate your coverage.

Local Service, Close to Home

Our office is on Delaware Ave in Kenmore, and our team serves the communities around us. When you call during business hours, you reach people who know the area.

Bundle Your Coverage

Home, auto, valuables, and other coverage can be reviewed together. Bundling can help keep your policies simple to manage with one team, one point of contact, and a clear view of your coverage.

Personal Guidance

Ask questions and explore your options with a licensed insurance professional who takes time to explain what each coverage does and why it matters for your situation.

Fast Changes

Adding a vehicle, updating your address, or changing coverage can often be handled quickly, so you spend less time on paperwork and more time on what matters most.

Convenient Contact

Reach us by phone, email, or stop on in. You can also get support through GEICO's app 24/7.

Questions about your coverage? We're right here in Western New York.

Licensed in NY, NC & FL · Product availability varies by state.

Connect With Craig Maitland

Let's Talk About What Matters to You.

From your home and vehicles to your boat and valuables, Craig Maitland's office is ready to discuss your insurance needs.

GEICO Exclusive Agency · Serving Buffalo & Western New York · Licensed in NY, NC & FL

Licensed Beyond New York

Rooted in Buffalo. Licensed Beyond New York.

Buffalo and Western New York will always be home for The Maitland Group LLC. While our primary focus is serving our local community, Craig Maitland is also licensed to offer insurance products in North Carolina and Florida.

Whether you're relocating, purchasing a second home, or exploring insurance options in either state, our office can help you discuss available coverage options.

Licensed to offer insurance in New York, North Carolina, and Florida. Product availability and eligibility vary by state.

Primary Service Area

Buffalo & Western New York

Tonawanda, Amherst, Williamsville, Clarence, Kenmore, and surrounding communities.

Additional Licensed States

New YorkNorth CarolinaFlorida

No physical office in North Carolina or Florida. Eligibility and product availability vary by state.

Contact

Connect With Your Local Office

Reach The Maitland Group LLC to discuss available GEICO insurance options for your home, vehicles, and valuables.

GEICO Local Office logo

The Maitland Group LLC

Craig Maitland · GEICO Exclusive Agency

3618 Delaware Ave, Suite 400
Buffalo, NY 14217
Serving Western New York · Phone & In-Office Inquiries
Based in Western New York | Licensed in NY, NC & FL

Office Hours

Monday–Friday
9:00 AM – 5:30 PM
Saturday
Closed
Sunday
Closed

Office hours are in Eastern Time.

Get a Quote Today